When comparing muzzleloading rifles to muzzleloading revolvers, the primary differences lie in their design, purpose, and functionality. Muzzleloading rifles are typically long-barreled firearms designed for greater accuracy and range, making them ideal for hunting and precision shooting. They require the user to load powder, a projectile, and a patch (if applicable) directly into the barrel from the muzzle end. On the other hand, muzzleloading revolvers are shorter and more compact, featuring a rotating cylinder that allows multiple shots before reloading. While they are less accurate over long distances compared to rifles, revolvers are prized for their ease of handling and faster follow-up shots. Ultimately, the choice between the two depends on the intended use—rifles for long-range precision and revolvers for close-quarters or convenience in shooting multiple rounds. Both types embody the charm of traditional firearms and offer a rewarding shooting experience for enthusiasts.

      In May I bought a .50 caliber Thompson Center New Englander. It's my very first rifle of any kind. Until holding my mentors' Hawken, I had never held a rifle in my life. I was unsure how i would feel, having my own rifle, shooting and cleaning it. From a distance it seems like a lot more trouble than a simple revolver. The loading procedure for a rifle is a bit drawn out, powder, patch, ball, ramrod down the barrel. But as I think about it more and more, the loading procedures are basically the same. I've fired 11 black powder revolvers, multiple rounds and quite a few hours on the range. On the flip side of that, the 22 rounds I've fired in my rifle seem more enjoyable by far. As a beginner I made the assumption the revolver would be a more simple process. Using paper cartridges, loading would take less time, be cleaner and easier. As of today, that hasn't been the case. I have struggled to load my revolvers, cap jams, and nipple clogs have been a constant problem. I realize this can be attributed to my lack of experience and knowledge. I can admit I'm not knowledgeable enough to form a more educated and definitive conclusion on which is better. But i can say as it stands at this moment, the muzzleloading rifle is my "go to" for a simple and enjoyable percussion firearm experience.