Muzzleloading Rifles...Better than Revolvers?

Published on 2 July 2025 at 13:15
First shots from my first rifle

My first shots with my Thompson Center New Englander                           Thompson Center New Englander    

When comparing muzzleloading rifles to muzzleloading revolvers, the primary differences lie in their design, purpose, and functionality. Muzzleloading rifles are typically long-barreled firearms designed for greater accuracy and range, making them ideal for hunting and precision shooting. They require the user to load powder, a projectile, and a patch (if applicable) directly into the barrel from the muzzle end. On the other hand, muzzleloading revolvers are shorter and more compact, featuring a rotating cylinder that allows multiple shots before reloading. While they are less accurate over long distances compared to rifles, revolvers are prized for their ease of handling and faster follow-up shots. Ultimately, the choice between the two depends on the intended use—rifles for long-range precision and revolvers for close-quarters or convenience in shooting multiple rounds. Both types embody the charm of traditional firearms and offer a rewarding shooting experience for enthusiasts.

 

      In May I bought a .50 caliber Thompson Center New Englander. It's my very first rifle of any kind. Until holding my mentors' Hawken, I had never held a rifle in my life. I was unsure how i would feel, having my own rifle, shooting and cleaning it. From a distance it seems like a lot more trouble than a simple revolver. The loading procedure for a rifle is a bit drawn out, powder, patch, ball, ramrod down the barrel. But as I think about it more and more, the loading procedures are basically the same. I've fired 11 black powder revolvers, multiple rounds and quite a few hours on the range. On the flip side of that, the 22 rounds I've fired in my rifle seem more enjoyable by far. As a beginner I made the assumption the revolver would be a more simple process. Using paper cartridges, loading would take less time, be cleaner and easier. As of today, that hasn't been the case. I have struggled to load my revolvers, cap jams, and nipple clogs have been a constant problem. I realize this can be attributed to my lack of experience and knowledge. I can admit I'm not knowledgeable enough to form a more educated and definitive conclusion on which is better. But i can say as it stands at this moment, the muzzleloading rifle is my "go to" for a simple and enjoyable percussion firearm experience.

Add comment

Comments

There are no comments yet.